Medical Malpractice Insurance Brokers for Physicians

DrsCoverage medical malpractice insurance specialists

When it comes to medical malpractice insurance, one-size-fits-all doesn’t work - especially for doctors navigating career shifts, complex risk profiles, or high-stakes specialties. That’s where a broker makes the difference.

A medical malpractice insurance broker doesn’t just connect you with policies. We work as a strategic partner - evaluating your risk, comparing carriers, and helping you secure coverage that aligns with your specialty, your state, and your stage of practice. Whether you're opening a new practice, leaving a hospital position, or preparing for retirement, the right broker brings clarity to a complicated decision.

This page breaks down how brokers work, how they differ from going directly to an insurance company, and why the right broker can save you time, help protect your finances, and support your long-term career goals.

Key Takeaways for Physicians and Surgeons
  • Brokers work for you, not the insurance company - offering independent, unbiased guidance.
  • Access to multiple carriers allows for competitive quotes and better-fit policy options.
  • Specialty-specific insight helps you avoid gaps, especially in high-risk or complex cases.
  • No extra cost to you - brokers are typically paid by the carrier, not the client, with no additional cost added to your premium.
  • Support extends beyond quoting - many brokers help with renewals, tail coverage, and policy changes.
  • Ideal for doctors at every stage - whether you’re starting out, expanding, relocating, or retiring.

What Is a Medical Malpractice Insurance Broker?

A medical malpractice insurance broker is your partner in the insurance world. Unlike agents who represent one company, brokers work independently - on your behalf - to find coverage that fits your unique situation.

We don’t work for an insurance carrier. We work for you.

That means we’re not here to push a single product. Our job is to assess your practice details, risk profile, and goals - and then match you with options from multiple A-rated malpractice insurance carriers. Whether you’re in private practice, part of a medical group, or working locum tenens across multiple states, a broker helps you compare the market and avoid coverage gaps you might not see on your own.

Good brokers bring clarity to complex decisions - especially when you're switching jobs, expanding a practice, navigating prior claims, or planning for tail coverage. It’s about more than just getting a malpractice insurance policy. It’s about getting the right strategy behind it.

Do Brokers Help Renewals or Policy Changes?

Many physicians assume a broker’s job ends once the policy is in place - but a good broker remains a long-term resource as your needs evolve.

That said, it’s important to understand where brokers step back - and where your insurance carrier steps in.

Renewals & Adjustments:
As your practice grows or changes, your policy should too. We’ll review your coverage annually, reassess your risk profile, and compare market options if a better fit emerges. Whether you're expanding, relocating, or making any other adjustments, we’ll help you make informed decisions without the paperwork headache.

Career Transitions & Tail Coverage:
From leaving a group practice to retiring, major changes often require tail coverage for a claims-made policy. We help doctors evaluate options and navigate transitions to avoid gaps in protection - without overpaying.

Why Work With a Broker Instead of Going Direct?

When it comes to medical professional liability insurance, going directly to a single carrier might seem faster - but it often means possibly missing out on better options.

A broker works independently, with access to multiple A-rated carriers - not just one. That gives you the ability to:

  • Compare quotes, terms, and coverage structures side by side
  • Understand how different policies fit your specific risk profile
  • Uncover opportunities for better insurance rates or broader protection
  • Avoid common pitfalls that come from not knowing what to ask

Most doctors don’t have the time to shop around, let alone analyze the fine print of policy exclusions, tail provisions, or defense cost structures. A broker simplifies the process and gives you a more complete picture of what’s available - and what’s at stake.

This is especially important if you're in a high-risk specialty, have prior claims, or operate a non-traditional practice model like telemedicine or concierge care. The wrong policy - or a missed detail - can cost far more than a premium.

With a broker, you’re not just getting a quote. You’re getting strategic guidance from someone who understands the coverage landscape - and works for your best interest, not the carrier’s.

A graphic showing a comparison of using a medical malpractice insurance broker vs going directly to a carrier.

Additional Benefits of Working With a Medical Malpractice Insurance Broker

Here’s how a broker adds value beyond the quote:

  • Streamlines the Process
    Instead of submitting separate applications to every carrier, a broker can typically use one recent application to request initial quotes from multiple insurers. That means less paperwork - and less time away from your patients.
  • Highlights Gaps Before They Become Problems
    From overlooked retroactive dates to missing tail coverage, small details can carry big consequences. A broker helps flag inconsistencies or misaligned limits early in the process.
  • Brings Specialty-Specific Knowledge
    Each specialty carries its own risks - and not all carriers price or cover them the same way. Brokers understand these nuances and help match you with the right carriers based on your practice profile and state requirements.
  • Supports Both Straightforward and Complex Cases
    Whether you're early in your career, transitioning to a new role, or managing past claims, brokers can access both standard and non-standard markets to find solutions that fit your situation.
With a broker, you’re not navigating blind or relying solely on a carrier’s perspective - you’re working with someone who looks at the full picture, so your coverage reflects where you are and where you’re headed.

Do Brokers Cost More?

This is one of the most common questions doctors ask - and the answer surprises many.

Most brokers don’t charge a fee when helping you find a policy.

Brokers are typically compensated by the insurance carrier through a commission that’s already built into the premium. Whether you go direct or use a broker, the premium is usually the same.

A graphic showing the benefits of using a medical malpractice insurance broker at no extra cost to you.
At DrsCoverage, we don’t charge anything to help you find a policy, compare options, or walk you through coverage decisions.

Tip: Brokers aren’t just for complex cases - they’re a smart move for any physician who wants to avoid the time and risk of going it alone.

Healthcare Professionals We Serve

Whether you’re in private practice, part of a group, or just starting your career, our brokerage is built to meet doctors where they are. We work with physicians and surgeons across a wide range of specialties and practice settings.

Clients We Serve:

  • Solo Physicians – including early-career doctors and independent practitioners
  • High-Risk Specialists – OB/GYNs, neurosurgeons, orthopedic surgeons, general surgeons, plastic surgeons, anesthesiologists, and beyond
  • Physicians with complex risk profiles or prior claims

  • Medical Groups – from small partnerships to multi-state practices
  • Locum Tenens Providers – tailored coverage for flexible, short-term assignments
  • Telemedicine & Concierge Practices – addressing unique risks in personalized and virtual care settings
Tailored for Your Specialty

Your specialty impacts everything from premiums to policy structure. We help you avoid gaps, understand core policy differences, and choose coverage that fits your risk profile - whether that means higher surgical limits, occurrence vs. claims-made, or tail coverage planning.

Example: For OB/GYNs and neurosurgeons, we can walk through how claims history and delivery volume may affect tail costs - and how to plan for those costs well in advance.

We understand the pressure to protect your license, livelihood, and reputation - and that one-size-fits-all solutions rarely work in medicine. That’s why we focus on alignment, not just access.

Why Physicians Choose DrsCoverage

DrsCoverage is backed by a team of industry professionals with more than 100 years of combined medical malpractice insurance experience, including in underwriting, offering the steady, informed support physicians appreciate when reviewing coverage or planning for a transition.

Experience with Surgical Risk

Our brokerage supports surgeons and other procedural specialists, giving us a sharper understanding of how carriers evaluate complexity, procedure mix, prior acts, and county-level risk. Our team understands the realities of high-exposure practice.

Team-Based Coverage Review

At DrsCoverage, we take a collaborative approach to medical malpractice insurance. Your dedicated broker leads the process, with support from an experienced team that contributes added insight during coverage review. It’s a structure that further strengthens the ability to identify potential gaps and present the full scope of available options, while keeping your coverage aligned with your specialty and practice setting.

Access to Admitted, E&S, and RRG Markets

We have access to a wide range of A-rated admitted carriers, E&S markets, and physician-focused RRGs. That gives doctors meaningful options whether they practice in a high-severity venue, have a complex history, or simply want to compare grounded alternatives across different market types.

Concierge-Level Support Throughout Your Career

From first-year coverage to renewals, transitions, and tail planning, you have a responsive broker who explains coverage in clear terms and stays available as your practice evolves. Since carrier pricing is the same with or without a broker, this level of support comes with no added cost.

Start Your Quote Request or Speak With the Broker

You can schedule a consultation with a licensed broker or request quotes whenever you’re ready. If you have a recent application or renewal packet, feel free to send it over - it usually helps us get initial indications more quickly. A DrsCoverage broker is available to help at any point in the process.

Thank you! We’ve received your request and will reach out to you shortly. Please check your email for further details.
We’re sorry, something went wrong while submitting your form. Please try again or contact us at the email or phone number listed for assistance. We’re here to help!

Medical Malpractice Insurance Broker FAQs

Will I pay more using a broker?
No. Most medical malpractice insurance brokers are compensated by the carrier, not the client. That means your premium stays the same whether you go direct or work with a broker.
Can a broker help me with tail coverage or prior acts?
Yes. If you're switching jobs, retiring, or moving between claims-made policies, a broker can walk you through tail insurance options or help you explore prior acts coverage with your new carrier.
How do brokers compare insurance quotes across carriers?
We work with multiple A-rated carriers and submit your application to those best matched to your specialty, location, and risk profile. We also have access to excess and surplus lines for more complex cases. This allows us to present a range of options to fit your specific needs and risk profile.
Can brokers help me switch carriers or move to another state?
Absolutely. Whether you're relocating or expanding your practice, a broker can help assess state requirements and coordinate new coverage. Brokers need to be licensed in the state where they provide service to you.
Do I need a broker if I’m just getting started?
If you are looking for coverage, then yes - especially when you’re just getting started. Malpractice insurance isn’t a one-size-fits-all product. Your first policy will set the foundation for your coverage structure, premium trajectory, and long-term costs. A broker can help you avoid common pitfalls, like choosing the wrong retroactive date, missing tail coverage obligations, or paying for more than you need.

Working with a broker gives you access to multiple carriers, side-by-side comparisons, and guidance on how your specialty and practice setup affect pricing. There’s no extra cost to use a broker - carriers pay the commission, whether you go direct or through a professional.

For new grads, newly independent physicians, or doctors launching a PLLC or PC, involving a broker early can save time and help structure your first policy to match your practice and long-term goals.
Have more questions - or ready to see your options?
A DrsCoverage insurance broker will review your information and begin requesting quotes from top-rated carriers based on your specialty, location, and coverage needs.