Neurosurgery sits at the intersection of high clinical complexity and high liability exposure. In Texas, the combination of tort reform, regional access gaps, and demanding call schedules makes malpractice insurance both expensive and nuanced. Before diving into premiums and policy structures, it’s worth grounding yourself in the core facts that shape the coverage environment for neurosurgeons practicing in Texas.
Quick Facts at a Glance
Neurosurgery carries some of the highest malpractice premiums in Texas, with wide variation based on geography and subspecialty.
Premiums for neurosurgeons in Texas typically range from $60,000 to over $110,000 per year for mature claims-made coverage at standard limits (1M/3M), depending on geography, case mix, and underwriting history. Houston and Dallas tend to have the highest base rates, driven by large jury verdicts and dense claim activity. San Antonio and Austin fall in a moderate band, while rural areas may see slightly lower base rates - but often face fewer carrier options.
Carriers price neurosurgery policies based on more than just location. Cranial cases, complex spine surgeries, and trauma call can all push premiums higher. They’ll also weigh your claims history, whether you’re in solo or group practice, and your hospital affiliations. The type of policy - claims-made or surplus lines - also impacts your rate.
Neurosurgery already carries a high-risk designation, but certain factors can push premiums sharply higher:
Early Tail Planning
If you’re leaving a group, changing jobs, or transitioning to 1099, confirm who’s responsible for tail - and get it in writing.
Texas Insurance Code §1901.253 requires at least 90 days’ written notice for any premium increase and for cancellation or non-renewal (other than for non-payment or loss of license).
Most neurosurgeons in Texas are insured under claims-made policies, but it’s important to understand how coverage forms differ - especially when switching carriers, joining a group, or leaving a hospital-employed role. Each structure has tradeoffs, and the right fit often depends on your practice setting, career stage, and risk exposure.
The overwhelming majority of Texas neurosurgeons carry claims-made coverage. These policies cover claims filed during the active policy period, as long as the incident occurred on or after the retroactive date. Your retro date can be preserved when switching carriers only if the new insurer agrees to provide prior-acts (nose) coverage. If not, you’ll need tail coverage from the old policy to maintain protection for past acts.
For neurosurgeons changing jobs, going 1099, or leaving a group, claims-made coverage requires careful planning at transitions - even a short gap in coverage can leave prior work unprotected.
If you're covered under a claims-made policy and leave without replacement coverage, you'll likely need tail. Tail coverage allows you to report claims for services performed during your active policy - even after it ends.
Neurosurgeons should consider carrying tail that matches or exceeds the 10-year statute of repose in Texas. Exceptions and nuances exist- such as cases involving minors or allegations of fraudulent concealment - which can extend exposure beyond the standard 10-year repose. Some carriers offer options like 3-year, 5-year, or unlimited duration tails - but keep in mind that most lawsuits are filed well after the incident, especially in pediatric or delayed-diagnosis cases.
Who pays for tail depends on how your exit is structured. Employed neurosurgeons may have it covered in their contract, but solo physicians and independent contractors typically fund it themselves. Tail is a major cost to plan for - and often ranges from 150% to 250% of your mature annual premium. For 1099 neurosurgeons or those leaving hospital employment, this can represent a six-figure expense. Advance planning and clear exit terms are key.
Occurrence coverage is triggered based on when the incident occurred - even if the claim is filed years later - eliminating the need for tail coverage. While this can simplify transitions, it's rarely available to neurosurgeons in Texas due to the specialty’s high-risk profile and delayed claim exposure.
When offered, it's typically in narrow scenarios:
When available, occurrence through surplus lines or RRGs often comes with tighter terms and less flexibility than admitted claims-made coverage.
Learn more about claims made vs occurrence coverage.
If you're billing through a professional entity - such as a PLLC or PA - you may need entity coverage in addition to your individual policy. Vicarious liability arises when your entity is named in a suit for your actions or those of your staff.
You can choose shared limits (where the entity and individual draw from the same policy limits) or separate limits (each has its own coverage cap). For solo neurosurgeons with no employees, shared limits are often sufficient. But if you employ advanced practice providers (APPs), or bill as a group, separate limits or standalone entity coverage may be necessary.
Carriers also evaluate APP exposure - especially for first assists or mid-levels performing procedures under your supervision.
If you bill through an entity, DrsCoverage can help structure coverage so both you and your practice are protected without paying for unnecessary duplication.
Beyond standard malpractice coverage, some neurosurgeons opt for policy endorsements or companion policies to expand protection in high-risk or high-profile practices:
These protections are not always included in base malpractice policies and may require endorsements or a separate policy for full protection.
Texas has one of the most structured tort reform environments in the country. For neurosurgeons, the combination of statutory caps, procedural deadlines, and unique emergency standards shapes how claims are filed, defended, and ultimately paid.
Since the 2003 tort reform, Texas caps non-economic damages at $250,000 per physician and $250,000 per institution, with a maximum of $750,000 total per case if multiple hospitals or facilities are named. These caps apply only to non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering. Economic damages - including lost wages, future care, and medical expenses - remain uncapped.
For neurosurgeons, the practical takeaway is that catastrophic claims still carry seven-figure exposure because economic damages are uncapped.
Callout Box: Texas Cap Structure
Texas medical liability claims are tightly governed by statute. Key deadlines and requirements include:
Sources: Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code §§74.051, 74.153, 74.251, 74.351 (available via FindLaw and Justia).
Texas applies a “willful and wanton” negligence standard for certain emergency settings. In practice, this means plaintiffs must prove more than ordinary negligence when care is rendered:
For neurosurgeons, this most often comes into play during trauma call or emergent consults. The scope is narrow, but when it applies, it raises the bar for plaintiffs and can make a case more defensible.
Emergency-Care Standard
Several Texas cases continue to shape the malpractice landscape:
Texas case law continues to evolve - and entity liability remains one of the most active fronts for neurosurgery practices.
Neurosurgery-Relevant Case Notes
Medical malpractice outcomes - especially for neurosurgeons - are often shaped by a small number of high-severity claims. However, headlines about large jury awards rarely reflect the broader landscape. In Texas, most malpractice claims are resolved through dismissal or settlement, not trial.
The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) publishes closed claim reports that offer a more accurate, data-driven look at outcomes. These reports show how many claims result in payment, average indemnity amounts, and the primary contributing factors across specialties.
According to the Texas Department of Insurance Closed Claim Report, only 29.2% of medical malpractice claims in Texas closed with an indemnity payment in 2021. The average payment was $317,447, with a median of $100,000. Read more of the TDI report on our Texas Medical Malpractice Insurance Guide.
Among surgical specialties, neurosurgery consistently appears near the top for average payout severity. Factors like permanent neurologic injury, delayed diagnosis of spinal cord compression, and alleged technical errors drive both verdict risk and settlement value.
Malpractice underwriting for neurosurgeons in Texas goes deeper than the average application. Carriers often ask for surgical case mix, hospital affiliations, and group coverage details up front. But that doesn’t mean the process has to be complex.
If you’ve completed a malpractice application within the past year, that’s often enough for our team at DrsCoverage to pull early indications from multiple carriers. If not, we’ll start with a short intake form to get quotes moving.
From there, once we’ve identified the most competitive carriers, we’ll walk you through the full application for that company - ensuring it includes the neurosurgery-specific details underwriters want to see.
Schedule a consultation with a licensed medical malpractice insurance broker. You can also request a quote to get started or email us with any questions. If you have a recent carrier application (such as last year’s), it may help us provide initial indications faster. A DrsCoverage broker is available to assist you at any stage.
(3).svg)